Imagine this: the Atlanta Braves, a team known for their strategic moves, are facing a critical decision that could shape their future. But here's the twist: their current shortstop situation is more precarious than you might think. After letting Dansby Swanson go in 2022, the Braves have struggled to find a consistent presence at shortstop, cycling through eleven players since the start of 2023. Only Orlando Arcia's magical first half in 2023 came close to league-average performance. And this is the part most people miss: the 2026 season might seem set with Ha-Seong Kim and Mauricio Dubón, but both are free agents afterward, leaving the Braves with a looming question mark at shortstop for 2027.
Kim, a Scott Boras client, signed a one-year, $20 million deal with Atlanta after a disappointing 2025 season with the Tampa Bay Rays. He's expressed a desire to bounce back, focusing on staying healthy and potentially increasing his stolen base attempts. If he returns to his 2023 form, he'll be a highly sought-after free agent. But here's where it gets controversial: can the Braves retain him? With their 'Atlanta Max' salary limit at $22 million, it's unlikely they'll match his market value. An early extension seems like the obvious solution, but Boras-represented players rarely sign before free agency. However, the possibility of a lockout and the qualifying offer system might incentivize Kim to stay, especially with his friend Jurickson Profar already under contract with Atlanta.
If Kim leaves, Dubón could step in as the everyday shortstop. While Anthopoulos trusts his defensive abilities, Dubón's offensive decline over the past three seasons raises concerns. His strength lies in his versatility, having played every defensive position except catcher and winning two American League utility Gold Gloves. But is relying on him as the primary shortstop a sustainable strategy? It could lead to overworking starters, a risk for a team aiming for a World Series.
The free agent market for shortstops in 2027 looks sparse, with Kim as the top option. This might push the Braves to explore trades. Potential targets include young players like Jeremy Peña, CJ Abrams, and Zach Neto, or veterans like Corey Seager and Trevor Story. Here's a bold idea: Matt McLain of the Cincinnati Reds. Despite a shoulder injury and underperformance, his speed and defensive skills make him an intriguing option if the Braves believe his bat can rebound.
Internal options like John Gil, Alex Lodise, and Cody Miller are unlikely to be ready by 2027, emphasizing the need for a veteran presence. The Braves' front office must balance competing in 2026 with extending their competitive window. Not having a solid shortstop plan for 2027 could hinder their division and championship aspirations. Will they secure Kim, trade for a young talent, or take a chance on a veteran? The decisions made today will echo into the future, and I, for one, can't wait to see how this unfolds. What do you think? Is there a clear path forward, or is this a dilemma with no easy solution? Let's discuss in the comments!
